I did something similar with an imported STL egg model I created then imported. I copied/pasted into a new project and played with the height and depth settings quite a bit to be sure it still came out looking like an egg! (I think I had to use a 999 Height if I recall).
I did end up with a 'mysterious' uncarved line around the largest diameter area of the egg, though. It was explained to me that this was caused because I created keepout zones (zero carve regions) that (of course) were even with the top surface of the board. The largest diameter of the egg was shy of the surface by a small amount. Because this was a square blank (i.e., not rounded first), the zero carve region was observed and created that line around the egg's largest diameter which was a tad lower from the surface. This behavior is a deliberate choice because the alternative would have been that the jig would only accept round dowels instead of both square stock AND round stock.
So, when playing with Height and Depth settings to avoid or workout ptn distortion, the screen preview might appear "clean", but it's possible the actual carve might have some unintended raised areas that need to be sanded away. The alternative is to allow the 4.25" default and put up with some air carving.